Why was FOX TV´s exposé of magic bad for everyone?
He who can no longer pause to wonder and stand rapt in awe, is as good as dead; his eyes are closed.
- Albert Einstein
I just finished watching "Secrets of Street Magic Revealed" by FOX TV. As you probably suspect, I am upset and disheartened by the airing of this show. As a fellow magician I think that I speak the collective opinion that this show is a disaster for all close-up workers.
It is akin to a grand heckler. Sure we all put up with those that try to find fame in discrediting magic, but one should distinguish between the good-natured and misguided personalities of these people and FOX TV. Fox did it for one reason, and one reason only, namely money.
The magic world was shocked by the success of David Blaine's special. It was a refreshing look at magic from outside of the normal perspective. The criticisms of Blaine by other magicians are all of a technical manner, i.e. his routines were mostly store bought and lacked ingenuity - but to give credit where credit is due one must admit that Blaine got it right. He brought the magic to the people. His impromptu act was magic in its most beautiful form - magic done right before people's noses.
The only real fault by Blaine was his use of post-editing. He should not have used camera tricks at all - the beauty of the illusion is not diminished without camera edits but the magical tradition is very much slighted by the use of them. From now on all magic on television is open to the charge of camera trickery. That is a true shame.
Fox tries the ultimate mis-direction with their script. They turn the benevolent entertainment of street magic into something akin to Voodoo worship. In their closing line, "So the next time somebody tells you that they have magical abilities you'll know how it's done. And if somebody actually does we would like to meet them," one can see the overt hostile attitude of Fox. It is as if the magician is evil. This is their justification for the special, or at least it tries to justify the special, because it portrays magicians as people who lie and use trickery and therefore must be bad people.
The truth of the matter is that magic is one of the purest arts around. It requires a lot of skill and many long hours of practice. At its most simplistic magic is done to entertain, but it reaches much further than that. Magic empowers the audience to believe what should not be and to engage in wonderment at the world. Magic for entertainment is not uesd to defraud people, nor do we harm our audience in any way.
At it's heart magic is an implicit contract. It is a contract between the magician and the audience. He agrees to practice diligently in order to amaze the audience and the audience agrees to suspend reality for a short time. It is this two-way street that makes magic the awe inspiring gift that it is. Magic is perfect symbiosis - neither side is harmed in any way.
Exposing the beauty of the trick is equal to robbing a child of the idea of Santa Claus. In deciding the merits of going through life knowing how it is done, or amazed at the idea that it can be done ... ask yourself whether you would rather have a world full of wonder and imagination, or a world with no Santa Claus.
Magic Frequently Asked Questions
What is mentalism?
How does the shell game work?
What do I need to do the Shell Game?
What are some good books on mentalism?
How is the "Linking Paper Clips" trick performed?
How can I prepare for the unexpected while performing?
What if someone demands to examine my cards or coins?
What does "abracadabra" mean?
Do I have to learn a variety of magic?
Is it okay for me to allow videotaping?
What kind of rabbit is best for magic?
Should I include a rabbit in my magic act?
Is it okay to tell people how my tricks are done?
How do I handle hecklers?
When my time is up, should I just leave?
How important is misdirection?
Can I shoot my own audition videos?
Should I announce my tricks before I do them?
What must I learn to be a better performer?
Why should I volunteer to do non-profit and charity shows?
How many card tricks should I do?
What´s the difference between a trick and an illusion?
What are Platform, Parlor and Cabaret Magic?
What kind of magic is done in restaurants and clubs>
What is Close-Up magic?
Why do I need business cards?
Why should I join a magic organization?
How should I talk to an audience?
Should I include bits of my live shows in my performance tape?
Are other magicians rivals or friends?
How do I specialize in Mentalism?
Where can I find good jokes and one-liners for my act?
Are there summer camps for aspiring young magicians?
Should I Specialize?
How much should I practice?
What are some good magic magazines?
Why was FOX TV´s exposé of magic bad for everyone?
What magazines are available on the topic of magic?
What are some non-English words for "magician?"
Do I have to tailor my performances to specific audience?
What are the different types of magic specialties?
Are there any really old books about magic?
Are there any historical references to medieval magic?
What should my performance video tape contain?
Where in the NY area can I go to magic school?
How can I add a twist to the Jumping Rubber Band trick?
What are some good books for learning magic?
Can I perform with only card tricks?
Who is the patron saint of magicians?
What´s the derivation of the word ´illusion´?
How should I "act" onstage?
Where can I buy used props, or sell my old stuff?
How important are movement and choreography?
Is it alright to imitate other magicians?
What kind of magic do street performers do?
What does the word ´Magian´ mean?
How do you do that rubber band trick?
Where did the word ´magic´ come from?
What´s the etmology of the word ´magic´?
What is Linking Ring Magazine?
What is Escapology?
What do I do when I make a mistake?
Who is Magical Edd?
Is it okay to exploit stupid people?
How can I project a "feeling" that sets the mood for my audience?
What is the collective term for a group of magicians?
Should my act have a theme?
How can I develop a theme for my act?
Is it OK to repeat a trick if someone asks?
Can I use animals in my act?
Was the Tony Curtis film about Harry Houdini historically accurate?
How did Harry Houdini die?
What are the benefits of joining a magic society?
Why should I join a magic club?
What´s the Chinese (Mandarin) word for magician?
How can I keep my act exciting?
How do I locate contacts to find good jobs?
Where can I find good books and magic tricks?
Where did the term ´hocus-pocus´ originate?
Who were Los Reyes Magos?
Is it important to practice even the simple tricks?
How many tricks should I learn?
Do I have to plan out my performance in advance?
Do I have to check my equipment all the time?
What does ´hocus-pocus´ mean?
Where can I find good upscale stage magic equipment?
Where can I find magic classes?
Where can I learn more about physical theatre?
What is Magic Unlimited?
What is the Japanese word for magic?
What are the key elements of a great performance?
How can I improve my performance and keep my act alive?
Where can I buy used props and illusions?
What´s a great place to buy magic items?
Where can I buy magic items online?
How smart is the average audience?
Should I specialize or learn all sorts of magic?
Where can I get magical domain name for my website?
Where can I find new features for my act?
Is there a website where I can buy books, props and so on?
Where can I post a free website for my magic performances?
Where can I find an agent?
What kind of business card should I have?
How can I get table-hopping gigs?
Do I need an audition tape?
Is it okay to shoot my own performance tapes?
Why should I have a website?
What kind of photos should I have in my portfolio?
Where can I find up-to-date information on marketing and promotion?
Where can I have my services listed FREE online?
Is it alright to use special effects in a performance tape?
Why should I do a performance tape?
How can I get TV air time for my performance video tape?